Sunday, April 6, 2025

Banning Biological Reality is Ridiculous!


 What could be more ludicrous than declaring biology to be against the law?

Over the past few months, since Trump was inaugurated again, information has been disappeared by the administration. Datasets have been taken down, historical images removed from archives, websites have been removed or revised, research defunded, and books have been purged from libraries. In just one example, the United States Naval Academy--a college--has removed 381 books from its library thus far, having been so directed by Pete Hegseth, our current Secretary of Defense. Hegseth may be incompetent at actual military leadership, spilling secrets on Signal, but he's great at imposing his ideology that the military should be the preserve of cis straight white men. . .

The books removed include studies on the KKK and lynching, on women in the Holocaust, on trans issues, on 19th century masculinity, on slavery. Maya Angelou's I Know Why the Caged Bird sings was removed. All of these were framed as violating federal executive orders on "DEI" or "gender ideology," and thus figuratively to be burned.

You know what else was removed? Books on intersex statuses. Intersex statuses are inborn, and are found in all animal species-- humans and dogs and songbirds and mice and tropical fish. This is how nature works: sex is way more complicated and interesting than some singsong child's story!

But on his first day in office, Trump signed an executive order written by Project 2025 authors--radical Christian nationalists--titled "Defending Women from Gender Ideology Extremism and Restoring Biological Truth to the Federal Government." The media reporting on this was shallow. (So much media reporting now is shallow, because there's so much chaos going on that nobody can keep up.) The EO was framed as an anti-trans statement, often with some discussion of popular opposition to the participation of trans women in sports. Then the story sank in the flood of developing news.

But that EO continues to have a powerful impact, being the basis of a huge, ongoing wave of purges of books and research projects and federal employees. So you should know what the EO declares to be law under President Trump. The EO states that is that there is no such thing as gender, only biological sex. And biological sex is stated to be a binary of male and female that is set at conception.

Thus, the EO does not just declare that people cannot gender transition, that nonbinary gender identity does not exist, that trans people must be detransitioned on their passports, that schools and prisons and scientific studies etc. etc. must not recognize gender transitions, and all the other transphobic discrimination it requires. It also declares that intersex statuses do not exist.

This is ridiculous and bizarre! You can no more erase the fact that intersex babies are born all the time than you can erase that curly-haired babes are born all the time by making a proclamation. The authors' vision of physical sex--that at the moment of conception, we're all either XX or XY, which will determine which of two gonads we develop, which in turn will determine what our genitals look like, is that singsong child's myth. Some embryos are XXY, some are XXYY, some are XX/XY. Some embryos that are XX develop into fetuses that look typically male, with phallus and testes. Some that are XY develop into fetuses that look typically female, with vulvas. Fetuses of any genotype can develop intermediate ovotestes. Fetuses of any genotype can develop intermediate genital configurations. That's how biology works!

But the EO declares this biology to be intolerable, to be ideology, to violate the Trump-declared reality of the singsong children's myth. And the federal government is taking action to impose this inversion of biology and ideology on the nation--for example, by banning books on intersex from the US. Naval Academy library.

All book bans are evil. But banning books on biology as "denying biological reality" has the cherry on top of being ridiculous.